Eye for an Eye (2025)
A haunting supernatural horror about guilt, grief, and a dream-stalking monster who makes bullies pay the ultimate price.
Eye for an Eye - Movie Information
- Original Title: Eye for an Eye
- Release Year: 2025
- Directed by: Colin Tilley
- Type: Movie
- Genres: Horror
- Runtime: 1h 41m
- Original Language: English
- Spoken Languages: English
- Release Date (Theatrical): July 3, 2025 (QA)
- Alternative Titles: Olho por Olho (BR), Somewhere in Dreamland (US), Night Terror (UK), Night Terror (XI), Night Terror (IE)
- Production Companies: Ley Line Entertainment, glassEyeballs, WME Independent, HanWay Films
- Production Countries: United States of America, United Kingdom
Eye for an Eye - Plot
Anna, grieving the sudden death of her parents, relocates from New York to a small Florida town to live with the grandmother she has never met. Isolated, vulnerable, and in need of friends, she finds brief solace in the company of two local teens. But when she becomes complicit to their unforgivable act of violence, she finds herself ensnared by Mr. Sandman – the twisted soul of a tormented child who haunts bullies’ dreams before feasting on their eyeballs when they finally wake – Anna must right her wrong before becoming a victim of this gruesome curse.
Eye for an Eye - Trailer
Watch the official trailer and see Mr. Sandman’s nightmare world come to life:
You can’t escape your dreams.
Where to Watch Eye for an Eye
Looking for where to watch Eye for an Eye?
Compare all viewing options available in your region on JustWatch ↗
Eye for an Eye - Cast & Crew
Director(s)
- Colin Tilley
Main Cast
- Whitney Peak
- Golda Rosheuvel
- Finn Bennett
- Laken Giles
- S. Epatha Merkerson
- Carson Minniear
- Wynn Reichert
- Ben Bladon
- Oliver J Green
- Zariah Boyles
Writers
- Elisa Victoria
Producers
- Tim Headington
- Theresa Steele Page
- Rachael Fung
- Nate Kamiya
Eye for an Eye - FAQs
Where can you watch Eye for an Eye (2025)?
Eye for an Eye (2025) is available to stream on Starz and its affiliated channels, including the Starz Amazon Channel, Starz Apple TV Channel, and Starz Roku Premium Channel. It can also be rented or purchased on Amazon Video, Apple TV Store, Google Play Movies, YouTube, and Fandango At Home. Kanopy offers free access.
Is Eye for an Eye based on a graphic novel?
Yes, Eye for an Eye (2025) is based on a graphic novel. The film’s screenplay was written by Elisa Victoria, adapting the source material into a supernatural horror narrative centered on a cursed entity known as Mr. Sandman who targets bullies through their dreams.
Who are the main actors in Eye for an Eye?
The film stars Whitney Peak as Anna, Golda Rosheuvel as Patti, Finn Bennett as Shawn, Laken Giles as Julie Cross, S. Epatha Merkerson as May, Carson Minniear as Conner, and Ben Bladon as the terrifying Mr. Sandman, among others.
What is Eye for an Eye (2025) about?
After losing her parents, teenager Anna moves to a small Florida town to live with her estranged grandmother. She befriends two local teens but becomes complicit in a violent act, awakening Mr. Sandman — a supernatural entity that haunts bullies’ dreams and devours their eyes upon waking.
What is the Mr. Sandman curse in Eye for an Eye?
Mr. Sandman is a twisted supernatural being — the tormented soul of a child — who infiltrates the dreams of bullies and those complicit in acts of cruelty. Once he has haunted his target, he feasts on their eyeballs when they wake, making escape nearly impossible without confronting the original wrong.
Does Eye for an Eye have a post-credits scene?
There is currently no widely confirmed information about a post-credits scene in Eye for an Eye (2025). Given the film’s standalone supernatural horror premise, viewers are encouraged to stay through the credits to check for any additional footage when the film becomes available on Starz.
Who directed Eye for an Eye (2025)?
Eye for an Eye (2025) was directed by Colin Tilley, a filmmaker widely recognized for his acclaimed work in music videos before transitioning to feature-length horror. The film marks a significant step in his narrative filmmaking career, blending dream logic with visceral supernatural horror.
When was Eye for an Eye (2025) released?
Eye for an Eye had its initial release on June 20, 2025, with a wider release noted as July 3, 2025, in select markets including a QA screening. The film was produced in the United States and the United Kingdom by Ley Line Entertainment, glassEyeballs, WME Independent, and HanWay Films.
More About Eye for an Eye
Explore further details about Eye for an Eye on these authoritative film databases: