Stranger with My Face (2009)
A Lifetime thriller about an adopted teen who uncovers a dangerous secret twin with chilling plans for her life.
Stranger with My Face - Movie Information
- Original Title: Stranger with My Face
- Release Year: 2009
- Directed by: Jeff Renfroe
- Type: Movie
- Genres: Thriller, Mystery, Drama, TV Movie
- Runtime: 1h 36m
- Original Language: English
- Spoken Languages: English
- Release Date (Theatrical): August 26, 2009
- Alternative Titles: Un Rostro Desconocido (ES)
- Production Companies: Bauman Entertainment, Howard Braunstein Films, Lifetime
- Production Countries: Canada, United States of America
Stranger with My Face - Plot
After the shocking and untimely death of her husband, Shelley Stratton (Catherine Hicks) moves her daughter Alexis (Emily Hurst) and her adopted daughter, Laurie (Alexz Johnson), to their remote summer house in hopes of giving her family a fresh start. As Laurie begins to settle in and put her life back together, she gets the eerie feeling that she is constantly being watched. Laurie's uneasiness grows when people start claiming to see her in places that she has never been. The family's delicate state begins to unravel when Laurie unearths the dark past, discovering a twin sister that she never knew she had. Laurie is forced to delve deeper into her twin's secrets, for as it turns out her twin has been locked up for years! Laurie must now understand their strange connection in order to prevent her sister from taking over her life and harming her loved ones. Based on the book by author Lois Duncan
Where to Watch Stranger with My Face
Looking for where to watch Stranger with My Face?
Compare all viewing options available in your region on JustWatch ↗
Stranger with My Face - Cast & Crew
Director(s)
- Jeff Renfroe
Main Cast
- Catherine Hicks
- Andrew Francis
- Alexz Johnson
- Beau Mirchoff
- Emily Hirst
- Grace Sherman
- Luisa d'Oliveira
- Nhi Do
- Bill Marchant
- Joanne Wilson
Producers
- Ted Bauman
Stranger with My Face - FAQs
What is Stranger with My Face about?
Stranger with My Face follows Laurie Stratton, an adopted teenager who moves to a remote summer house after her father's death. She soon discovers she has a secret twin sister who has been locked away for years and is now determined to steal her identity and harm the people she loves.
Does Laurie's twin sister actually take over her life?
That's the central tension driving the whole film. Lia, Laurie's long-hidden twin, uses their mysterious connection to infiltrate Laurie's world — appearing in places Laurie has never been and manipulating those around her. Whether she succeeds makes for a genuinely suspenseful watch.
Where can you stream Stranger with My Face?
You can watch Stranger with My Face for free on The Roku Channel, Pluto TV, Tubi TV, and Plex. It's also available through the Shout! Factory Amazon Channel if you prefer that route. Plenty of no-cost options to choose from.
Is Stranger with My Face based on a book?
Yes! The film is based on the 1981 young adult novel of the same name by Lois Duncan, the acclaimed author also known for I Know What You Did Last Summer. Duncan's novel blends psychological suspense with elements of astral projection, and the Lifetime adaptation brings that eerie premise to screen.
Who stars in Stranger with My Face?
Alexz Johnson leads the cast as Laurie Stratton and her twin Lia Abbot, delivering a dual performance at the heart of the story. Catherine Hicks plays their mother Shelley, with Beau Mirchoff, Andrew Francis, and Emily Hirst rounding out the family and supporting cast.
How does the twin connection work in the film?
The film leans into a supernatural angle — Laurie and Lia share a psychic bond that allows Lia to project herself into Laurie's life from a distance. This eerie connection is what makes people spot "Laurie" in places she's never visited, building the film's creeping sense of dread.
Who directed Stranger with My Face?
Jeff Renfroe directed the film. The Canadian director is known for working across genre television and film, and he brings a steady hand to this Lifetime thriller, keeping the supernatural mystery grounded in family drama while maintaining tension throughout.
Is Stranger with My Face worth watching?
If you enjoy Lifetime-style psychological thrillers with a supernatural twist, this one delivers. Alexz Johnson's dual role is the real draw — she handles both sides of the twin dynamic with conviction. It's a solid adaptation of Lois Duncan's novel that fans of suspenseful TV movies will appreciate.
More About Stranger with My Face
Explore further details and databases for this film.